Emily Tevebaugh

Staff Member Name


  • Title: Account Manager
  • Department: Commercial
  • Location: Greenfield

Emily Tevebaugh works in Commercial lines processing renewals, endorsements, all farm policies, and bonds. She also handles all commercial claims for the Greenfield office. She works alongside Paul McManus and Derek Rogers on commercial accounts and with Tyler Edon and Derek Rogers on the farm accounts.

A team member since 2002 Emily is a great asset to our team with almost 13 years in the insurance business. For a year she worked as a teller for Greenfield Banking Company before Ken Brooks and Gary Pence offered her a job with Pence Brooks Bolander & Shepherd Insurance. 

At home, Emily is the proud mother of three girls: Aubrey, Michelle, and Paige and is a loving wife to her husband Robert for almost 10 years. She keeps busy with her kid’s school lives and various sports teams. She enjoys being outdoors with her family, friends, and two dogs, Moose (Boxer) and Shelby (Boston Terrier). She attends St. Michael Catholic Church in Greenfield, IN. Emily recently received her Associates Degree from Shepherd University.

Click here to read our featured client testimonials.