Shepherd Insurance 2025 Mergers and Acquisitions Overview
With our 2025 partnerships now established within the organization, we are excited to introduce the latest mergers and acquisitions that have joined the Shepherd Insurance family. Each partnership represents a shared commitment to service, strong relationships, and a people-first approach. These agencies bring unique strengths, community history, and teams who truly care about the clients they serve.
Across several states, these additions help us grow with purpose. They expand our geographic reach while protecting the hometown feel and trusted service that defines Shepherd Insurance.
Our CEO, Quinn Shepherd, shares his perspective on last year’s progress:
“What makes these partnerships meaningful is the people behind them. Each agency comes with its own story, its own relationships, and its own values. We are honored they chose Shepherd, and we look forward to growing together in a way that supports their employees, their clients, and their legacy.” – Quinn Shepherd, CEO
Together, we continue our mission to deliver comprehensive insurance solutions rooted in knowledge, integrity, and genuine care.
Meet Our Newest Partner Agencies of 2025
HJ Mitchell – Albion, IL
Founded in 1984 and acquired by Randy Hallam in 1991, HJ Mitchell has served Eastern Illinois with longstanding community relationships and a commitment to trusted, local service. Once operating three locations, the agency now serves clients from its single Albion office. By joining Shepherd Insurance, HJ Mitchell continues its 40‑year legacy with expanded resources and the same hometown approach clients rely on.
SafeMetrics – Carmel, IN
Founded in 2006, SafeMetrics has built a respected presence in Central Indiana through its reliable support and trusted client relationships. As a certified Woman-Owned Business Enterprise (WBE), the agency has long been recognized for its professionalism and steadfast dedication to the organizations it serves. Partnering with Shepherd Insurance strengthens their ability to support clients while preserving the principles that have guided their success.
Strong Tower Risk Management – Naples, FL
Strong Tower Risk Management is a Naples‑based independent agency known for its warm, relationship‑driven approach. Their team has earned steady loyalty across Southwest Florida by focusing on consistency, accessibility, and genuine client support. Joining Shepherd Insurance allows Strong Tower to continue serving their community with enhanced tools and broader capabilities.
Bensolve Insurance Services, Now Shepherd – Louisville, KY
Since 2016, Bensolve Insurance Services has provided responsive, client‑first guidance to businesses across the Louisville region. The agency’s strong community ties and practical expertise have shaped its reputation for clarity, care, and reliability. Now operating from our Louisville office, Bensolve strengthens its impact with access to additional resources and a larger support network, while maintaining the personal service at the heart of its identity.
The Reisert Group, now Shepherd – Louisville, KY
Founded in 1884, The Reisert Group carries more than a century of tradition grounded in integrity and strong client relationships. Guided by multiple generations of the Reisert family, the agency built its legacy on dependability and honest guidance. Now part of our Louisville office, the Reisert team continues its long‑standing mission with the expanded support of the Shepherd Insurance network.
The Budd Agency – Winamac, IN
Deeply rooted in its Winamac community, The Budd Agency is known for its attentive service and neighbor‑focused approach. With our Winamac office and The Budd Agency now working together under one roof, clients benefit from a combined team offering strengthened support and the same personal service their community has trusted for decades.
HRM Insurance – New Palestine, IN
HRM Insurance Services has built its reputation on honesty, dependability, and a people‑first culture. The agency’s strong ties to the New Palestine community and commitment to doing things the right way have shaped its identity. By joining Shepherd Insurance, HRM continues its tradition while gaining access to broader resources and long‑term growth opportunities.
Capitol Insurance – Indianapolis, IN
Founded in 1981, Capitol Insurance is a family‑owned agency serving northeast Indianapolis with a warm, trustworthy, and service‑driven approach. Their nine‑person team is known for its experience, strong work ethics and genuine care for clients. As part of Shepherd Insurance, Capitol strengthens its long‑standing mission through expanded support and enhanced access to carriers.
Honoring Their Legacy While Supporting Their Future
Every agency joining Shepherd brings unique strengths, trusted relationships, and deep local roots. Our priority is to honor each agency’s legacy while providing the expanded resources of a Top 50 Largest Independent Agency.
Our partnership model ensures agencies maintain their independence, their culture, and the way they serve their communities, now with the support, carrier access, and tools to thrive long‑term.
Together, We Thrive
At the heart of our continued success are the dedicated individuals who show up every day for their clients with professionalism, empathy, and commitment. As we welcome our 2025 partner agencies, we remain focused on supporting our people and delivering the promise of the Shepherd Advantage.
Whether you’re an agency exploring a partnership or simply curious about what makes Shepherd different, we would love to connect.
