Shepherd Insurance Welcomes Capitol Insurance Group

May 15, 2026

INDIANAPOLIS, Indiana – Shepherd Insurance is proud to welcome Capitol Insurance Group to the Shepherd family, marking another step in Shepherd’s continued growth across Indiana and the Midwest.

 

Founded in 1981, Capitol Insurance Group is a family-owned, Indianapolis-based agency known for delivering customized insurance and risk management solutions to businesses, churches & nonprofits, and individuals. Through this partnership, Capitol clients will continue working with the same trusted local team, now supported by Shepherd Insurance’s expanded resources, broader carrier relationships, and additional expertise.

 

“Partnering with Shepherd Insurance was a milestone decision for our 44-year, three generation family agency, grounded in care for our clients and employees,” said Tony Grahn, President of Capitol Insurance Group. “It has unlocked resources and opportunities that strengthen our clients and advance our team in ways we could not have reached independently!”

 

Shepherd Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving clients across multiple states, with a focus on delivering customized coverage solutions backed by responsive, relationship‑driven service. The addition of Capitol Insurance Group broadens Shepherd’s reach in Indianapolis while bringing a unique specialization in church and nonprofit insurance that complements its existing capabilities.

 

“Capitol Insurance represents the best of what an independent, family-rooted agency can be,” said Quinn Shepherd, CEO of Shepherd Insurance. “Their longstanding dedication to doing what’s right for clients and employees aligns seamlessly with our own approach, and we look forward to building on that foundation together.”

 

For over 45 years, Shepherd Insurance has helped clients navigate risk through thoughtful, customized insurance solutions. Headquartered in Carmel, Indiana, Shepherd has access to more than 200 insurance carriers to serve businesses and families throughout the country.

 

To learn more about our Mergers & Acquisitions, visit shepherdins.com/mergers-and-acquisitions. To view all Shepherd Insurance locations, visit shepherdins.com/find-us.

 

About Shepherd Insurance

Founded in 1977 and headquartered in Carmel, Indiana, Shepherd Insurance is among the Top 50 largest independent insurance agencies in the United States, offering customized insurance solutions including commercial and personal insurance, employee benefits, risk management, and financial services to clients nationwide. Privately held, Shepherd employs more than 650 professionals across 45 offices and 6 states and is consistently recognized as a Top Workplace nationally and locally for its people-centered culture.

To learn more, visit shepherdins.com and follow Shepherd Insurance on social media.

 

MEDIA CONTACT

Blair Brewer

bbrewer@shepherdins.com

502.657.2345