WHO WE ARE
Founded in 2014, the Port Charlotte team, formerly Arnold Insurance, has proudly served Charlotte County and the surrounding community with a commitment to personal service, trusted guidance, and insurance solutions built around real people and real lives. What began as a locally owned agency rooted in Southwest Florida has grown into something even stronger, while remaining grounded in the same values our clients know and trust.
Today, the Arnold Insurance team is proud to be part of Shepherd Insurance, expanding our resources while preserving the local relationships that have always set us apart. This partnership brings together the hometown care with the strength of Shepherd Insurance, an independent agency serving individuals, families, and businesses across multiple states.
For our clients in Port Charlotte, Englewood, and surrounding counties, that means the best of both worlds:
- A local team that understands the unique needs of residents, business owners, and visitors to Southwest Florida
- Broader market access and expanded carrier options
- Additional expertise, technology, and support, without losing the personal touch
Whether you’re protecting your home, vehicle, business, or future, our team takes the time to understand what matters most to you. We specialize in home, auto, flood, and commercial insurance, offering customized solutions designed for the realities of coastal living and the evolving needs of our community.
We believe insurance should feel personal because protecting what matters most to you is personal to us. We’re proud of where we started, excited about where we’re going, and honored to continue serving our community and neighbors with clarity, care, and confidence.
SERVICE YOU CAN DEPEND ON
Rooted in our community, our team delivers trusted guidance, personalized coverage, and responsive support, every step of the way.
LOCAL EXPERIENCE, REAL RELATIONSHIPS
Our local team understands coastal living, seasonal residents, and the local business landscape, and we take the time to know you, not just your policy.
PERSONAL GUIDANCE
Thoughtful coverage recommendations tailored to your life, business, and goals, with proactive reviews as your needs change.
EXPANDED RESOURCES, FAMILIAR FACES
Access to Shepherd Insurance’s broader carrier network, tools, and support, while continuing to work with the same trusted local team.
RESPONSIVE SERVICE & LONG-TERM ADVOCACY
Clear communication, fast follow‑up, and a team that’s here for you before, during, and after a claim.
CLIENT'S TALK
"Kyle and his staff are fantastic! They insured everything we have! Autos, home, and our business! Excellent Customer Service and great rates!"
Cyndi H.
"Exceptional, professional, friendly, and very knowledgeable. I feel I received an excellent policy review, and the replacement policy was much less than the other carriers' policy. Highly recommend you speak with this agency before replacing or renewing your homeowners (HO3) with your current carrier."
George H.
"Shepherd Insurance is fantastic, the staff is professional, and easy to work with on my homeowner's insurance. Thank you, Shepherd Insurance!"
Cindy A.
WE'RE HERE FOR YOU
We’d love to hear from you. If you need assistance, have questions about our group of Shepherd partner companies or are simply looking for more information, we’re eager to help.
REQUEST A QUOTE
Please fill out the form below and one of our team members will be in touch to provide the assistance you need.
FIND US
Headquartered in Carmel, Indiana, with offices throughout the country, we are here to assist you with all of your insurance, benefits, and financial needs.
1357 S McCall Rd
Port Charlotte, FL 33981
941.214.8668
941.827.8776
